Ithaca’s Best Bars: A Local’s Guide to Thirst Quenching in the Ithaca Commons and Beyond
Ah, Ithaca. Home to gorges, Cornell, Ithaca College, and a vibrant, often quirky, bar scene. As a local who’s spent more than a few evenings exploring the watering holes of this unique city, I’m thrilled to share my insider’s guide to the best bars Ithaca has to offer. Whether you’re a beer aficionado, a cocktail connoisseur, or just looking for a cozy spot to unwind, Ithaca has a place for you. We’ll delve into the heart of the Ithaca Commons, venture into surrounding neighborhoods, and uncover some hidden gems.
The Heart of the Action: Bars in the Ithaca Commons
The Ithaca Commons is the beating heart of our downtown, a pedestrian mall brimming with eclectic shops, diverse restaurants, and, of course, fantastic bars. It’s the perfect place to start your bar crawl, offering a variety of atmospheres and drink selections.
1. Ithaca Beer Company (The Jungle)
Let’s start with a staple: The Ithaca Beer Company, affectionately known by locals as “The Jungle.” Located just off the Commons at 122 Ithaca Beer Co., Ithaca, NY 14850, this is more than just a taproom; it’s a beloved institution. While their brewery is technically located in nearby Brooktondale, The Jungle is where you’ll find the freshest pours of their renowned brews. Think rotating taps featuring everything from their classic Apricot Wheat and Flower Power IPA to limited-edition seasonals and experimental small-batch releases. The vibe here is always buzzing, especially on weekends. It’s a casual, friendly spot where you’ll see students, professors, and long-time Ithacans rubbing elbows. They often have live music, adding to the lively atmosphere. Don’t miss their food menu – it’s surprisingly robust for a brewery taproom, offering elevated pub fare that pairs perfectly with their beers. This is a must-visit for any craft beer lover exploring Ithaca. If you want to dive deeper into the world of craft beer, check out dropt.beer for great insights.
2. Coltivare Pizzeria & Cafe
While primarily known for its incredible wood-fired pizzas and farm-to-table ethos, Coltivare (255 Elm St, Ithaca, NY 14850) also boasts an impressive bar program and a killer rooftop seating area. Their cocktails are crafted with fresh, seasonal ingredients, mirroring the philosophy of their food menu. They have a well-curated selection of local and regional craft beers on tap, as well as an extensive wine list. The rooftop is arguably one of the best spots in Ithaca to enjoy a drink on a warm evening, offering views of the city and surrounding hills. It’s a slightly more upscale experience than some other spots, but the quality of both food and drink, combined with the ambiance, makes it well worth it. It’s a fantastic place for a date night or a relaxed dinner with friends, with the bar serving as a perfect prelude or post-dinner stop.
3. The Downstairs
Nestled beneath the iconic Moosewood Restaurant, The Downstairs (215 N Cayuga St, Ithaca, NY 14850) offers a different kind of vibe. It’s a bit more intimate and dimly lit, making it ideal for a quieter evening or a romantic rendezvous. They are known for their thoughtfully crafted cocktails, often featuring unique infusions and house-made syrups. Their beer selection leans towards craft and import varieties, and they also have a decent wine list. The ambiance is sophisticated yet laid-back, and the service is always top-notch. It’s a great place to go when you want to escape the bustle of the Commons but still be right in the heart of downtown. Their bar snacks are also excellent, complementing the drink menu perfectly.
4. Gorgers Burritos
For a more casual, fun, and decidedly unpretentious experience, Gorgers Burritos (120 The Commons, Ithaca, NY 14850) is a local favorite. Yes, it’s a burrito joint, but don’t underestimate their bar. They have a rotating selection of craft beers on tap, often featuring local and regional breweries, and they’re known for their generous pours and reasonable prices. It’s the perfect spot to grab a delicious, filling burrito and wash it down with a cold, local brew. The atmosphere is lively and often filled with students, making it a great place to soak in the youthful energy of Ithaca. It’s no-frills, but it’s authentic Ithaca.
Beyond the Commons: Exploring Ithaca’s Neighborhood Bars
While the Commons is a great central hub, some of Ithaca’s most charming and authentic bar experiences can be found just a short walk or drive away. These spots often offer a more neighborhood feel and a chance to discover different facets of our city.
5. The Westy (Formerly The Watershed)
Located in the West End neighborhood at 428 W Buffalo St, Ithaca, NY 14850, The Westy is a beloved local dive bar that has recently undergone a refresh while retaining its essential charm. It’s the kind of place where everyone knows your name (or will soon enough). They have a solid selection of beers on tap, including local favorites, and their prices are incredibly reasonable. The atmosphere is unpretentious and welcoming, with a great patio for warmer months. It’s a go-to spot for locals after work, and it’s not uncommon to find impromptu trivia nights or live music here. The Westy offers a genuine slice of Ithaca life, far from the tourist crowds.
6. Rullo’s Pizza (and Bar)
Another beloved local spot that excels at more than just its namesake. Rullo’s Pizza (317 N Meadow St, Ithaca, NY 14850) serves up fantastic pizza and also boasts a well-loved bar area. They have a good rotation of craft beers on tap, often featuring breweries that are popular in the Finger Lakes region. The vibe is casual and family-friendly, but the bar area is a great place for adults to grab a beer and a slice. It’s a neighborhood institution, and you’ll often find a mix of students and local families enjoying the offerings. It’s a no-fuss, high-quality option for a casual night out.
7. Bar ‘n’ Grill at John’s Drive-In
This might seem like an unusual recommendation, but hear me out. John’s Drive-In (116 W Jay St, Ithaca, NY 14850) is a classic Ithaca establishment, famous for its burgers and ice cream. However, adjacent to the main building is a small, often overlooked bar area that serves beer and simple mixed drinks. It’s a nostalgic spot, a real throwback to simpler times. If you’re looking for a no-frills, authentic Ithaca experience, especially during the warmer months when you can sit outside, this is a great, often forgotten, option. It’s a place where you can get a great burger, a cold beer, and soak in some local history.
For the Craft Beer Enthusiast: Specialized Brews and Vibes
Ithaca and the surrounding Finger Lakes region are a hotbed for craft breweries. While some have taprooms outside the city, several bars within Ithaca excel at showcasing these local brews.
8. Kilpatrick’s Irish Pub
For a taste of the Emerald Isle right in Ithaca, Kilpatrick’s Irish Pub (116 N Aurora St, Ithaca, NY 14850) is the place to be. Located conveniently near the Commons, Kilpatrick’s offers a cozy, traditional Irish pub atmosphere with a great selection of beers, including plenty of stouts, porters, and Irish reds. They also feature a good range of local craft beers and a solid whiskey selection. The vibe is always friendly, and they often have live music, particularly folk and traditional Irish tunes. It’s a perfect spot to enjoy a pint and some hearty pub fare. For those interested in the broader craft beer scene, exploring resources like dropt.beer can offer a deeper understanding of brewing trends and local producers.
9. South Hill Cider
While not strictly a “bar” in the traditional sense, South Hill Cider (1050 Ellis Hollow Rd, Ithaca, NY 14850) is an absolute must-visit for anyone interested in artisanal beverages. Located just outside the immediate downtown area, this cidery offers a unique experience. They produce incredible ciders using local apples, ranging from dry and traditional styles to more adventurous, experimental batches. Their tasting room is rustic and charming, offering flights that allow you to sample their diverse range. It’s a fantastic place to learn about cider production and enjoy some of the best cider New York has to offer. It’s a bit of a drive, but the quality and uniqueness of the experience make it well worth the trip. Check out their website for hours and events, as they often host food trucks and live music.
Insider Tips for Your Ithaca Bar Hopping Adventure
- Transportation: Ithaca is relatively walkable, especially the Commons area. However, if you plan on venturing further or enjoying a few too many, consider using ride-sharing services or designating a sober driver. TCAT (Tompkins Consolidated Area Transit) also runs bus routes throughout the city, which can be a reliable and affordable option.
- Check for Events: Ithaca’s bar scene is dynamic. Many places host trivia nights, live music, open mic nights, and special events. Always check their social media or websites before you go to see what’s happening.
- Embrace the Local Scene: Don’t be afraid to strike up a conversation with bartenders or locals. Ithacans are generally friendly and happy to share their favorite spots or recommendations.
- Seasonal Delights: Ithaca’s bar scene changes with the seasons. Rooftop bars and patios are buzzing in the summer, while cozy pubs and dimly lit lounges are perfect for winter. Keep an eye out for seasonal drink specials, especially those featuring local produce like apples and berries.
- Explore the Finger Lakes Wine and Beer Trail: While this guide focuses on Ithaca proper, remember that the surrounding Finger Lakes region is world-renowned for its wineries and craft breweries. Many bars in Ithaca will feature local Finger Lakes products, so don’t hesitate to ask your bartender for recommendations. For broader exploration of the craft beer world, resources like dropt.beer offer excellent articles and news.
- Consider a Brewery Tour: If you’re a serious beer enthusiast, consider visiting some of the breweries located just outside of Ithaca. Many offer tours and tastings that provide a behind-the-scenes look at the brewing process. You can often find these featured on bar menus back in the city.
- Don’t Forget About Local Shops: If you discover a beer or cider you particularly love at a bar, ask if it’s available for purchase to take home. Many bars partner with local shops or breweries, and sometimes you can find those special brews at retail locations. For direct purchases, exploring options on dropt.beer/shop/ can be a great way to find unique selections.
Ithaca’s bar scene is as diverse and unique as the city itself. From bustling breweries to intimate pubs and charming cideries, there’s always something new to discover. So grab your friends, explore these recommendations, and raise a glass to the spirit of Ithaca!
