Ithaca’s Premier Sports Bars: Where to Catch the Game and Enjoy Local Brews
As a proud resident of Ithaca, NY, I know that when game day rolls around, or even just a regular Tuesday night when the [team name] are playing, finding the perfect spot to cheer them on is paramount. Ithaca, a city known for its vibrant student population, stunning natural beauty, and fiercely loyal sports fans, boasts a surprisingly diverse array of sports bars. Whether you’re a die-hard Cornellian, a loyal Trojan, or just a casual observer looking for good food, great drinks, and a lively atmosphere, I’ve got you covered. Forget generic chains; we’re talking about places with local flavor, dedicated fan bases, and, of course, excellent beer selections. Let’s dive into the best sports bars Ithaca has to offer.
The Classics: Reliable Favorites for Every Game
When you think of watching sports in Ithaca, a few names immediately come to mind. These are the establishments that have consistently delivered a great game-day experience for years, becoming institutions in their own right.
1. The Downstairs (Formerly The Monkey House)
Located right in the heart of downtown Ithaca at 116 N Aurora St, The Downstairs is a perennial favorite for a reason. It offers a relaxed, unpretentious atmosphere perfect for catching any game. With numerous TVs strategically placed throughout the bar and restaurant, you’re guaranteed a good view no matter where you sit. Their menu features elevated pub fare – think gourmet burgers, loaded fries, and creative appetizers – that pair perfectly with their extensive beer list. They often have specials during major sporting events, so it’s worth checking their social media or giving them a call.
Insider Tip: The Downstairs is known for its excellent craft beer selection, often featuring local brews from the Finger Lakes region. If you’re looking to sample some of the best local IPAs or lagers, this is the place. Don’t be afraid to ask your server for a recommendation – they’re usually very knowledgeable about what’s on tap. It’s also a great spot for post-game analysis, with a crowd that’s engaged but not overwhelmingly rowdy.
2. Coltivare Pizza & Cafe
While primarily known for its incredible wood-fired pizzas and stunning garden patio, Coltivare (255-257 Elmira Rd) also has a dedicated following for watching sports, especially during football season. The atmosphere can get quite buzzing, particularly when there’s a big game on. They have a good selection of beers, and you can’t go wrong with pairing a slice (or a whole pie!) with your favorite team’s performance. The outdoor space, when open, is a unique experience, though perhaps not ideal for focused game-watching unless they have specific screens set up. Inside, the bar area is lively and offers a decent view of their televisions.
Insider Tip: Coltivare is incredibly popular, so expect crowds, especially on game nights and weekends. Arrive early, put your name down for a table, and grab a drink at the bar while you wait. Their pizza is worth the wait, and the energy of the crowd when a big play happens is infectious. It’s a fantastic place to experience Ithaca’s love for both good food and good sports.
Hidden Gems and Neighborhood Hangouts
Beyond the well-trodden paths, Ithaca has some fantastic spots that offer a more intimate or unique sports-watching experience. These are the places locals flock to, often with a strong sense of community.
3. Rullo’s Pizza
Located at 407 College Ave, Rullo’s is a beloved Ithaca institution, especially for students and residents near Cornell University. It’s more than just a pizza joint; it’s a neighborhood hub. They have a dedicated bar area with TVs that are usually tuned to whatever game is most popular at the moment. The vibe is casual, friendly, and often filled with passionate fans. Their pizzas are classic, satisfying, and perfect for sharing during a game. They also offer a decent selection of beers, including some local options.
Insider Tip: Rullo’s is fantastic for late-night games or when you’re looking for a no-frills, authentic Ithaca experience. It’s a great place to mingle with Cornell students and faculty. Don’t miss their classic pepperoni pizza – it’s a local legend. The staff are usually friendly and make you feel right at home, even if you’re not a regular.
4. Ithaca Beer Company (The Brewery & Taproom)
While technically a brewery and not a traditional sports bar, the Ithaca Beer Company’s Taproom (1220 Trumansburg Rd, Ithaca) deserves a mention. During major sporting events, especially those involving local teams or popular national leagues, they often have games playing on their screens. The atmosphere is relaxed and focused on enjoying their fantastic range of craft beers. Their food menu is also excellent, featuring pub fare and more. It’s a great option if you want to watch the game while appreciating some of the best beer brewed right here in Ithaca. You can explore more about their offerings and events on dropt.beer.
Insider Tip: The Taproom offers flights, so you can sample several of their brews before settling on a pint to enjoy during the game. It’s a bit more of a brewery vibe than a sports bar, so if you prefer a more laid-back setting with a focus on artisanal beer, this is your spot. Check their schedule, as they sometimes have special game-day events or food pairings.
For the Serious Fan: Places with Dedicated Viewing Areas
If your priority is maximizing your viewing experience with multiple screens, excellent sound, and a crowd that’s truly invested, these spots are worth seeking out.
5. Maxie’s Supper Club & Oyster Bar
Maxie’s (614 W Seneca St) is a long-standing Ithaca favorite, known for its Southern-inspired comfort food, seafood, and live music. While not exclusively a sports bar, they have a dedicated bar area with multiple TVs that get quite lively during popular games. The atmosphere is a bit more upscale than a typical dive bar, but the passion for the game is definitely present. They have a great selection of drinks and a menu that goes beyond typical bar food, making it a good choice if your group has diverse tastes.
Insider Tip: Maxie’s is particularly good for watching games where you might also want to enjoy some quality food. Their oysters are fantastic, and their BBQ ribs are legendary. The bar staff are generally attentive, and you can often request specific games if they aren’t already showing them. It’s a great blend of a nice dining experience with sports bar energy.
6. Ithaca Ale House
Located in The Ithaca Commons at 115 The Commons, Ithaca Ale House is a fantastic spot for a reason. It boasts a huge selection of draft beers – often over 50 taps – and a menu packed with delicious burgers, sandwiches, and appetizers. They have numerous TVs, making it a prime location for catching any game. The atmosphere is always buzzing, especially during big events. It’s a place where the beer selection is as serious as the sports being watched.
Insider Tip: With so many taps, it’s a beer lover’s paradise. Don’t hesitate to try something new or ask for a recommendation. Their pub trivia nights and other events add to the lively atmosphere. For a truly immersive sports experience with a fantastic craft beer selection, Ithaca Ale House is hard to beat. You can explore more about beer and brewery insights on dropt.beer/insights-news-blog/.
Beyond the Game: What to Expect in Ithaca
Ithaca’s sports bar scene is deeply intertwined with its local culture. You’ll find a strong presence of Cornell University and Ithaca College fans, and depending on the season, you’ll see plenty of support for NFL, NBA, MLB, and NHL. During college sports seasons, expect bars to be packed with students and alumni, especially for rivalry games.
Local Flavor: Don’t be surprised to find bars featuring local brews prominently. The Finger Lakes region is a hub for craft breweries, and most sports bars in Ithaca take pride in showcasing these local gems. This is where a site like dropt.beer/shop/ can be a great resource for discovering what’s available.
Transportation: Getting around Ithaca can be a bit tricky, especially on game nights. Parking can be limited in popular areas like The Commons or near Cornell. Consider using ride-sharing services, the local bus system (TCAT), or walking if you’re staying nearby. Always plan your transportation, especially if you plan on enjoying a few drinks.
Game Day Etiquette: Ithacans are generally passionate but respectful sports fans. While cheers and groans are expected, keep in mind that these are often community spots. Be considerate of other patrons, and enjoy the shared experience. If you’re rooting for the opposing team, be prepared for some good-natured ribbing, but most locals are friendly and welcoming.
Conclusion
Ithaca’s sports bar scene might not be as sprawling as in a major metropolis, but what it lacks in sheer numbers, it makes up for in local charm, excellent beer selections, and passionate fan bases. Whether you’re a student, a local, or just passing through, these establishments offer a fantastic way to catch a game, enjoy great food and drinks, and soak in the unique atmosphere of this vibrant city. So grab your jersey, pick your favorite spot, and get ready to cheer on your team – Ithaca style!
